| Crusades-Encyclopedia | |||||||||||||||
| Return to Crusades-Encyclopedia | |||||||||||||||
| Speech at Clermont-1095 | |||||||||||||||
| Pope Urban II's speech at Clermont in November of 1095 was the spark for what would later become known as the First Crusade. The popularity of Urban's speech is demonstrated by the relatively large number of surviving sources that claim to have recorded, in varying capacities, the words of the Pope. While different accounts enphasize different themes, all the accounts of the speech are in agreement on the enthusiastic response the Pope received from his listeners. Although dated, the late Princeton scholar Dana Carleton Munro produced some of the most important scholarship of lasting relevance on Pope Urban, the conditions surrounding his calling of the First Crusade, and his speech at Clermont. Munro's best works on these issues include "The Speech of Urban II at Clermont." American Historical Review 11 (1906), 231-40 and "Did the Emperor Alexius Ask for Aid at the Council of Piacenza 1095?" American Historical Review 27 (1922). He has also addressed the subject of urban's speech in other works including Dana Carleton Munro, The Middle Ages, 395-1272. New York: The Century Company, 1921. Munro has described Urban's speech as follows, The pope began by praising the valor of the Franks and re-calling to them the great deeds of their ancestors. Then he spoke of the necessity of aiding their brethren in the East, of the appeals for help that had come so frequently because of the victorious advance of the Turks. He dwelt at length upon the sufferings that were inflicted upon the Christians and upon the desecration of the holy places. He gave examples of cruelty, and aroused deep emotion in his hearers by pointing out the ma1ner in which the places they held most sacred were being defiled. Then emphasizing the special sanctity of Jerusalem, he declared that this was God's own work, that, for all who participated, the journey itself would take the place of all other penance. He urged them to engage in righteous warfare instead of wasting their strength and imperiling their souls by civil strife at home. He pointed out the evil conditions in France which reduced many to starvation, and compared with this the opportunity for acquiring homes in a land flowing with milk and honey, and l for securing at the same time eternal rewards. He urged them not to let any ties prevent them from entering upon this holy undertaking in which they would march with Christ as their leader. This speech aroused the utmost enthusiasm. Thousands pressed forward to take the cross. Urban seems to have been surprised at his own success, and found it necessary to attempt to check the excessive enthusiasm by ordering that women should not go without the consent of their husbands, that priests and monks should not join the movement without the approbation of their superiors, and that old men and children should remain at home. But he was powerless to stay the flood that he had set in motion. When ambassadors arrived on the following day to say that Raymond of Toulouse, the most powerful count in France, had taken the cross, success seemed assured. Dana Carleton Munro. The Middle Ages, 395-1272 (New York: The Century Company, 1921), pp. 242-255] Among the sources which claim to reproduce accounts of the speech are Robert the Monk, Balderic of Dol, The Gesta Francorum, Guibert of Nogent, Fulcher of Chartres, Ekkehard of Aurach, William of Malmesbury, Roger of Wendover, William of Tyre, and Odericus Vitalis. Additionally, there is some speculation that the so-called Letter of Alexius to Count Robert of Flanders may have been based in part on Urban's speech. Various versions of the speech made available online are linked to below. |
|||||||||||||||
| First Crusade- Crusades-Encyclopedia | |||||||||||||||
| Primary Sources of the First Crusade-Crusades-Encyclopedia | |||||||||||||||
| Fulcher of Chartres-Urban II: Speech at Clermont [Partial Text] Crusades-Encyclopedia | |||||||||||||||
| Robert the Monk-Urban II's Speech at Clermont [Partial Text] Internet History Sourcebooks Project | |||||||||||||||
| Ekkehard of Aurach- The Opening of the First Crusade [Partial Text] Internet History Sourcebooks Project | |||||||||||||||
| Collected Accounts-Urban II-Speech at Clermont [Partial Text] Internet History Sourcebooks Project | |||||||||||||||
| Letter of Alexius to Count Robert of Flanders-[Full text] Crusades-Encyclopedia | |||||||||||||||
| Dana Carleton Munro- Crusades-Encyclopedia | |||||||||||||||
| (c) Andrew Holt, May 2005- Permission is granted for electronic copying and distribution in print for educational and personal use. No permission is granted for commercial use. | |||||||||||||||